Rule for new suggestions on this forum

[Schizm]

The Designers and admin of Peloton suggested that it might be a nice idea to put a poll above every new suggestion form now on, with the following choices :

* Very bad idea
* Needs some improvement
* Neither good, nor bad
* Could have some potential
* Brilliant idea

So every suggestion can be evaluated on how all forum-visiting manager think about a suggestion (and not only those who shout the most or the hardest). Of course this is only for real and (almost) complete suggestions. Ideas that need some brainstorming or are very vague don't require this !

So what is your opinion about this suggestion ?

edit : Approved by a large majority please do follow this rule for any new suggestion.

[boucthesurvivor]

Bad idea...

Polls are not reliable, everybody knows it...

You want a poll for every new suggestion?? So each manager that have an idea will create a poll without searching in old threads.. :\
Or is it just for big suggestions that staff is working on?


ps : maybe there is something I didn't understand...

[droopy]

Is it possible change your poll choice after a while? I can imagine that your opinion can change after reading some posts of other players.

[thesmile]

i think it could be a nice idea however you may only accept the votes that come with comments....

[caner26]

We should only have a poll for ideas that have a chance to be inplemented

[jjvdh]

I think it is a greejt idea

Exchanging opinions/discussions is a bonus to the game.

grtz

[Ambi]

Since this poll is clearly over, wouldn't it be more logical to delete the sticky?

[Pissboy]

i agree, i'll just unsticky it, but if it's considered necessary we can always sticky it again.

[Schizm]

I don't agree completely , I will close the poll, but since there has been no announcement that new suggestions have to have a poll I 'll change the title and make it sticky again.

[barcaig]

i think that is good to moderate the ideas

some have too much in potencial to be working on peloton...but sometimes is not good to implement..